Book completed
May. 11th, 2025 11:11 pmAlien Clay, by Adrian Tchaikovsky. I’m afraid this book read too much like a thought experiment. For the first two-thirds of the book, almost, we just endure life on a penal colony planet – our narrator is an exobiologist who would have been quite professionally interested in the way this planet’s life works differently from Earth’s, except that he’s condemned to labor and die out here. There’s no real narrative suspense, because we have no sense that something could be done about his situation (life under totalitarianism is bad), and he’s not particularly likeable anyway. Then, suddenly, he and some of the others do have a major problem to address, and although he tells us right away that they do solve their new problem (getting back to the camp from a considerable distance), we also get to see how maybe they’ve solved their larger problem, either by emulating the way life works on this world or by becoming infected with enough of this planet’s molecules that they’ve now changed enough to make a difference. (Our narrator insists that he is no different biologically, he just sees things differently now, but he doesn’t seem entirely reliable in that regard, which kind of undercuts the point of the story.) It’s interesting, but it doesn’t really work as a story for the reasons I’ve described, nor as an allegory of standing up to totalitarianism, since the solution is essentially an upbeat horror story. I did like his metaphor of life on Earth as authoritarian at the individual level, where we want and need our bodies to have some centralized control over what’s going on internally, rather than just being a hodgepodge of symbionts like they are on this world, which is a more democratic system.